Saturday, 23 April 2016

Lisa Temple-Cox - fine artist / lecture


30th November 2015

This year of my graphic design studies is all about coming up with personal philosophy relating to projects realisation and general visual outcome in designing. Today as an example, I had a chance to hear a personal story from Lisa Temple-Cox, post-graduate student of Colchester Institute, fine artist practitioner, currently based in Essex.

She talked about her life journey in finding self-identity through deep research development. Firstly we hear about her Malaysian-British family background and childhood in Malaysia, where the line between reality and normality was rather blurred, as she emphasises (such a as a relative eaten by a snake seemed to be normal incident).

With her arrival to Great Britain she has discovered a new reality and she has found herself really interested in medical collections, such as Damien Hirst's instalments. Lisa likes the weirdness of it, suggesting something more than normal, different human recognition. All of it leads her to very deep and complex research and travelling to many museums located in few very different directions. Most of her research was done by drawing, which resulted in greater relation with the objects. She has started to see a real connection between art and biology, which both were in her sphere of passions. So she decided to become an artist and link those two within art. As she explained during the lecture, there was something very striking about teratological specimen, what she called her ''horrifying fascination'. Teratology is the study of abnormalities of physiological development or "study of marvels and monsters" 1670s (Harper, 2010). The subject unlocks human curiosity, but at the same time it's very disturbing, I would add incredibly disturbing. It's a bit like with Marcel Duchamp's door with a hole where viewer discovers a terrifying scene (this image has appeared in the previous lecture).




Étant donnés
Marcel Duchamp

Lisa finds the topic being a good direction for development of her own practice. She studies forms of art related to it, from Leonardo Da Vinci's first proper anatomical atlas (made from live drawings), to preservation techniques and heads in jars (powerful effect; it looks so realistic... although it isn't). She was presenting some preservation displays she's seen. She stated that ''baby specimen jars are compelling'', because of its elements of normality (realistic little hands). Well... that's where I got a bit confused and disguised. I wasn't sure if that was real embryo specimen or not... but either way it had to be made out of the real thing in my opinion. I understand that for science to be able to collect enough knowledge and understanding of human body, through years, it was necessary for health and medical reasons. Heads in jars may be used for medical schools and their education programmes (such as disease showing ones)...That's possibly acceptable as its not real thing. It was clever while there was no substitute. I think now, new technologies allow science to do the same graphically even better. There is no need for it.
However I totally disagree with these being an art. I would happily support the social opposition for it being displayed in the museums, as she mentioned, it's happened in some cases. It's too controversial and too disrespectful to this individualities of people that Lisa Temple-Fox finds amazing. Photographs and videos of baby in the womb of a mother is perfectly classified as an art, a document of new life and very personal memory for parents; inspiration for artists. But three-dimensionality and jar placement of parts or the whole of human bodies should be highly respected and definitely not displayed in the gallery setting or on the streets as posters as I don't think it's a view suitable for young children. Some of the images I've seen today were highly disturbing for me. There was a pinch of curiosity as well, but mostly I just didn't want to look at it at all. It's just to forbidden probably for religious reasons... possibly me being quite sensitive to such views or maybe simply because I just see no reason for displaying it. I reveals negative feelings.
Very similar feeling I had while visiting some exhibitions in London last year. I remember one part showing mad cows disease, including specimens of cow's head and brain. I didn't enjoyed it at all. It was disturbing and uncomfortable. I also never used to take many pictures if any at all of real human parts I've seen in the museums, such as skulls in Auschwitz, kings tombs in Wawel Cathedral in Krakow (Poland) or human bones from sarcophaguses of pharaohs in the British Museum, while visiting.


Albinus anatomy painting
Skeleton and rhino called Clara


Before photography has appeared, head casts and death masks were made for recognition and identification. Lisa has shown us one of the French classics, a beautiful, iconic in a way, an effigy of young suicide girl. In process of research and finding her own identity, she has also done a cast of her own face (French: moulage). And I think that was a breaking point in the whole lecture as even the title she composed related to it ('Making myself a monster' - self-portraiture teratological specimen.). Alien form was mentioned too... As she explains, that particular form of her face, additionally placed in an extraordinary circumstances, fully blurred boundaries, made free of any cultural identity. It was also about how other see us differently than we do (as mirror image isn't an exact likeness of ourselves). She photographed the outcome (white against coloured background). For the reason of making it she has shaved her hair completely (for second, proper, professional attempt)! She has also made copies and exhibited them (four jars: three of them containing a different liquid, such as milk, oil and urine; one with just water). As another result of her observation, she claimed that there is a difference in appearance of eyelids on deaf mask and mask made out of alive person (here: more tension).

Lisa Temple-Fox currently works at the museum in Ipswich and shares her experience with others by extra teaching sessions at university. She's done numerous research projects by finding connections of the objects she's seen; she's done book covers and curated exhibitions. She's found her identity, emphasizing that it's important to be comfortable with who you are.

The most important thing for me out of this lecture was seeing even more value in drawing as research (even if it isn't that good). Our active looking while recording with a pencil is more than good drawing skills. It means definite seeing, not just passive looking or using camera, it's registering all details of the object with own eyes. Visual research through drawing becomes a kind of sensation of it and it creates personal meanings. I agree, it's often possibly a good start for a brief; it may raise questions. I'm going to try using it more as a tool towards my project's solutions as I haven't done it quite enough so far.





Temple-Cox, L. (2015). Making myself a monster' - self-portraiture teratological specimen.

Teratology. Dictionary.com. Online Etymology Dictionary. Douglas Harper, Historian. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/teratology Accessed: December 04, 2015).

Commons.wikimedia.org, (2008). File: Albinus skeleton w less muscles.jpg - Wikimedia Commons. [online] Available at: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Albinus_skeleton_w_less_muscles.jpg [Accessed 4 Dec. 2015].

Art, P. (2015). Philadelphia Museum of Art - Collections Object : Étant donnés: 1° la chute d'eau, 2° le gaz d'éclairage . . . (Given: 1. The Waterfall, 2. The Illuminating Gas . . . ). [online] Philamuseum.org. Available at: http://www.philamuseum.org/collections/permanent/65633.html# [Accessed 4 Dec. 2015].













Social Media and Creative Coop


12 January 2016

Lecture: Social Media
By: Marc De'Ath 

Today we had a chance to attend an extra guest lecture by Marc De'Ath, creative director in a trio with Alan Peart (technical director) and Ben Philp (design director) in the Creative Coop team. He gave us some very useful tips regarding future cooperation with a client and running own business.





Project 2015, Creative Coop 


Firstly Marc drew a visual outline of what his company does and its social enterprise character (creativity for good, not just business where only profit matters). He gave examples and shortly described some of newest projects (such as the one above for network of artists in Essex). He emphasized various demands on the market and need of building a team for particular projects (similarly to GTF approach). He also talked about their connection with local public section organisations, such as charities, council and housing association. 

''We are called the Creative Coop and we help build strong communities, by developing user friendly online tools, offering fun and authentic creative communications and designing innovative programmes of community engagement.'' (http://marcde-ath.tumblr.com/creativecoop)

It seems to me like they follow their mission of purpose beyond profit. There are particular rules and approaches settled, making the group who they are. Examples of their work show deep engagement with their mission and business. I really liked the idea of helping some residents build their own Internet connection at home, free of charge. It supposed to help them with digital communication and give better opportunity to find job in digital economy.

To be exact, there were eight particular tips for future working in the industry he presented.
  1. Self Promotion (standing out of the crowd - perhaps not online...)
  2. Marketing Mix (cover everything, hit all possible channels in digital projects)
  3. User Led Design (audience and purpose/function consideration for a start; user = centre of the design, think of the users! their life styles, preferences, value for money etc.)
  4. Think Accessibility (access to technology on different platforms, considered audiences: elderly and disabled people)
  5. Being Responsive
  6. Agile Methodology (breaking the project down to smaller chunks - sprints; responding to what's most important for the client: team review 1-4 weeks for instance, feedback to inform the next step, final push, challenge & improve)
  7. Working with Developers (different mind switch, it can be difficult sometimes, make most of offer of what can be achieved; coding - designing cooperation)
  8. Business Modelling (open mind, working through, concept/fresh idea).


''Advertising almost killed my desire to design.'' (Marc De'Ath)



Marc De'Ath states that it's very important to believe in what you're doing, to have own moral compass. He said id has happened for him to turn down some work that didn't match and advised to refer to someone else when possible. I would love to try different designer's roles and that's definitely includes advertising. I think the experience of working on advertising doesn't need to be only bad and I'm hoping to find an advertising agency where I could possibly do some good ethically work and make good profit. Although I'm aware that it may be quite hard to find. Nowadays a lot of brands confuse their audience by green movement and having very different primary goals - pure profit (money comes first). He mentions Nike's new wayfinding when past record of exploitation in Chinese sweatshops doesn't matter as much when taking a job (care for present actions, making things better). Integrity and authenticity is the most important to change the world.

Our guest as every other describes a bit of his own background and starting own business which (as it usually is) was scary and difficult. It was easy to imagine and agree with all that has been said about tough start of new company. It's being financially insecure. It can be up and down. However it has to be worthy doing what you love in the way you want. I has to be more rewarding too.

Marc is part of the group of three as mentioned before and this company model not only let to stand out from the crowd, but also there is less pressure for paying potential employees. It's just them three friends relying on each other and in case of bigger project or another specialist required, the team is arranged. It gives more opportunities to get new clients with wider offer on board and good chance to cooperate with other creative, learning something new. Sometimes its essential to understand some certain, basic terminology, such as in conversation between web designer and web developer. It's important to go forward and making work.
He also talks about the idea of Coop name and its origin from the political movement in 1920s. It had their brand matching style and ethics; learning more about it has affected company's ways/designs. That's how these three independent people gathered together to do something as a team.


Marc also mentioned that digital technology can definitely let down and some details about Internet connection should be considered at the first stage of new project. It's for casual communication with the client reasons but in this case web design), it's also maintaining the product updates, diagnosing the problem when something fails etc. Constant frustration. That's why I cannot imagine working for web design. There's only as much design software and IT basics I can take :)

We were talking later on in our graphic design group (as the lecture was for all creative courses) with him about some more interesting details and practices. Marc emphasized the importance of designer's online presence this days and talked more about social media. I personally think that he puts to much pressure on updates while working on a project. It would be nice to put it somewhere in the schedule as a part of the job possibly on weekly or monthly basis. I think it's more valued at the beginning to promote yourself. However it cannot put the priority of actual project development and realisation on a side. It can be done in a bit of later stage as soon as considered and documented properly. I also hope to separate my job and personal, family life as much as I possibly can, with good time management... so I won't loose on any of it. There has to be a good balance, that's for sure in my case.  
Coop company has particular and clear work-flow, project management and set of digital tools being used (e.g. Slug instead of Skype, Google Drive, Dropbox). Marc gives few more advices: personal profile reflect on you professionally; you have to understand technology to promote yourself and show your personality and stories behind the processes/approaches/solutions there (chatting to people on Twitter etc. can be very effective while trying to look for clients). Meeting people face to face or even remote conversations, definitely help to engage with others and raise opportunities. He also said one thing which was really encouraging for a start in the creative industry: ''It's not just about big portfolio.'' Good online presence and social engagement makes half way of fitting in. Thinking of it this way surely encourages a fresher :)

It's definitely essential these days to have nice online presence. During the summer break especially, I want to concentrate on it a bit more and finally build professional website and possibly make personal blog (to present mature designer's personality and practice). Integrated public response is vital to arise somehow in the field of graphic design. As discussed today (which was very useful) blog should be well-considered tool for interaction and self-promotion (layout, content: who you writing for, who you are and what you stand for; anything picked from everyday life and experience put in interesting way). Employers possibly often look at blogs and websites and it's a chance to make much better entry to get the job; there is more possibilities than just with the CV.

Another thing we discussed was: are the web designers and generally graphic designers in good position at the moment as so many tutorials and online tools are available to anyone online? It is a bit tricky, and in fact, scary question... but I think not everyone can design and the results will vary. To get professional look people will hire professionals.

I quite liked the idea of giving away little designs while starting up a career as soon as is properly accredited and copyrighted (unless of course it's something more valuable). It's great self-promotion indeed and exposure is more important at this stage. Helping charities or even short term free experience could be another good solution for start.



























  







Jeremy Spencer: Feminisms and Visuality / lecture


7th December 2015 



Today's lecture by Jeremy Spencer touched a topic of feminisms' origin and movement waves across Europe. It was very useful and interesting and most of all, highly relevant in art and design field. Its principles and controversy are present in advertising where graphics are very affected. The lecturer has explained the theory really effectively, by using its visual reflection the whole way through. Very complex topic, but really well-structured.

''Feminism means the wish to end the subordination of woman to men in society.''
The First Wave of feminism faces issues such as: women restriction in property ownership (only inheritance and no real independence), no legal protection against sexual violence, discrimination in the workplace (lower payment for the same job as men, no allowance for maternity leave or applying for particular jobs).
There are different ways of understanding the representation of gender:
Stereotypes (guilt-ridden mother, self-indulgent flapper; sexist)
Collusion (femininity being elevated in some way)
Compensation (images manipulating women's consent to their subordination)
Recuperation (images negating or diffusing challenges to dominant - patriarchal meaning of gender).

The new way of thinking and feminist movement emerged in 1960s in America as anti-war and anti-colonial radical students rebellions ('Women of the world unite' banner'). It has considered gender as an organizing aspect for culture of society. It claimed that till then, men was favoured over women and that women are oppressed by empowered male. It was claimed that this is not natural, but cultural, social and historical process which can change. It was against women being a sexual consumer's objects in popular culture. Feminism has questioned and problematized several issues and demanded equal rights with man, opposed to traditional paternal exemplar of societies and everything within them (language, religion, culture, art). For change, post-feminism considers women as empowered individuals who can manage any activities that used to involve only men. Role of the women has changed a lot, especially during the middle of 20th and in the 21st century. Women are artists as much as men are; building and renovating houses, doing businesses, driving buses etc. Often dads look after children while ladies are at work. The washing machines and vacuum cleaners are not necessarily defining only woman role (house wife stereotype). In my opinion it's still relevant and happens in many families that I could simply point if required. I think, nowadays male side is more aware and considerate about equality and sharing obligations.

Feminism had appeared through several waves and there're few different kinds of the movement. There is radical feminism (foundation, all men=potential rapists and abusers); liberal feminism (equal rights); Marxist and socialist feminism (oppression of women=capitalist/private property system).

Women are obviously different physically from men (closer to nature, defined by body and ability to give birth), but they're also very different psychologically.



The Three Graces (1639)
Peter Paul Rubens
Museo del Prado, Spain 
Venus at a Mirror (1615)
Peter Paul Rubens
Liechtenstein Museum, Wenen

Two paintings above by Peter Paul Rubens, Baroque artist, represent a woman in his easily recognizable Rubenesque style (well-rounded bodies, blond hair). They are shown as ideals of beauty of their time, goddesses (mythological and allegorical aspects).

Women had to claim and demand their rights for many centuries, as a lot of them were previously exclusive just for men. Slowly women achieved their rights being equal with men. In 1970s feminism demanded complete control over own body (individual decisions regarding to pregnancy; abortion, contraception). It was claimed that women are exploited by man.

Annie Kenney and Christabel Pankhurst
campaigning for women's suffrage

In 2011 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada SlutWalk movement appeared after police officer commentary about woman avoiding dressing up like sluts. It became an international protest calling for an end of rape culture, especially against explaining or excusing rape by referring to any aspect of a woman's appearance; the way she looks, behaves or dresses. The examples of banners used in the young women march were very clear and simple: ''It's a dress, not a yes.'' or ''Yes means yes and No means no.''




Am I a feminist? - I  was not sure 100% what options are included in that question at first. I was never really into this topic too much, I mean feminist movement theories. Well all I knew that it's sort of against man and of course it could be just against injustice and inequality or actually against men as a group in all aspects. Personally I have had rather positive relation with male side in general. I think a lot of the time I get on even better with them than with the female side. Sometimes it's maybe easier for me to communicate and deal with men but... thinking about it.... two of my best friends are female... I think it depends more on personality not as much on sex. Well reading more about it I am definitely not a feminist or I am but only in particular issues. I agree that rights between man and woman should be equal and depending on required skills and knowledge, in case of employment for instance. I don't see a reason why woman wouldn't be able to take any role originally designed and destined just for men. I think men can do a great job at home stereotyped to be a female role (of course apart of giving birth and breastfeeding; although even breast milk can be now pumped out into the bottles and stored for few hours). I also want to add that becoming a mother doesn't permanently close social life and anything really that woman wants to do in life, perhaps depending only on determination, organization and level of commitment to motherhood. I think having a baby brings one of the most amazing feelings a woman can ever experience. It's indescribable and truly beautiful from its very beginning. I have now very personal perspective when talking about it. After having a baby myself and giving myself time to enjoy the new role, I have managed to start university. I got to know quite a few people who are parents and students in the same time. Some businesses can me managed easily from home. And yeah a lot of ladies start their own businesses. Technology went so far now that in my opinion only thing that can stop us from realizing most of our dreams is ourselves. Men and women are both equally relevant. We complete each other as human kind. It reminds me of very famous Polish comedy science fiction action film entitled ''Sexmission'' (Polish: Seksmisja) from 1984. The two protagonists, Max and Albert, wake up in an oppressive feminist society of post-nuclear world in 2044. Farce, politics and gender dynamics are blended together in this production.


'Sexmission' poster 1984



Rape or any form of abuse against women or men is a crime and I agree it touches mostly women indeed. It cannot be excused. I do not tolerate any sort of violence like that. However I think some form of female clothing can be inappropriate in particular ages or places; it can become purely provocative or even quite disgraceful. I think women should have those boundaries with dressing up purely for themselves to know their value and feel sexy, comfortable with their bodies, but not by purposely overdoing their fashion appearance and overexposing themselves. I think it may be more often sign of weakness as well...when the body is confident but mind isn't.
There are aspects of feminism I disagree with. I am rather quite old school person and I enjoy traditions and traditional gender issues in society. I think world is going well to far with breaking convention and allowing everything possible these days, I think it turns upside down and starts to choke on wrong understanding of freedom in all aspects.
I don't think homosexual relationships are a right thing, however I respect them as a human and I do have friends gays. Although I disagree couples like that should be able to adopt children. I strongly disagree with new gender theories of not defining child sex and let it chose either to boy or a girl. I am strongly against abortion. I think it's a murder of unborn child and it cannot be called anything else in any circumstances. I am possibly follower of Christian feminism which reinterpret and understand Christianity as the equality of women and men. There isn't a discrimination, it should be partnership and fulfilment between a couple.

Sarah Maple
The Opposite to a Feminist (2009)
C-Type, photograph
Signs series


Jeremy Spencer has pointed quite a few artists working through feminists philosophy. One of them was a young female British visual artist Sarah Maple. She performs very strong visual references to women's biological and social role in society. She plays with signs, body language, conventions or sort of taboo about natural processes and stereotypes. In great amount of her work she uses her self-portrait to send the message which emphasizes, as much as it can get, her personal statements. Her works are known internationally and its really inspirational.


Sarah Maple
Signs series (2007)
C-Type, photograph

Sarah Maple
Menstruate with Pride (2010-11)
Oil on canvas
As strong or possibly even more brave imagery comes from Sarah Lucas and Judy Chicago. ''Bitch''
by Sarah Lucas (another British artist) immediately suggests a woman bending over forwards. It provocatively exposes female sexual organs by placing melons and fish within the white t-shirt puled over the wooden table.


Sarah Lucas
Bitch (1995)

Judy Chicago, American feminist artist, breaks taboo of menstruation by making ''Red Flag'' showing up the body detail and a particular moment of bloody tampon removal (self-portrait). It's totally shameless and possibly a bit disturbing, but also really powerful. I think the image is very strong and gets its point and actually becomes a piece of art.



Judy Chicago
Red Flag (1971)
Photo-lithograph, 20" x 24" (Photo © Donald Woodman)


Judy Chicago
 The Dinner Party (1979)
Brooklyn Museum
''The Dinner Party'' is a massive installation which became an icon of feminist art in 1970s. It's a ceremonial banquet with 39 seats honouring mythical or historical famous women (symbolic history of women in Western civilization). The artwork is closed in triangular form. Each unique place-setting includes a hand-painted china plate with vagina-styled butterfly looking motifs (styled to represent individuals), ceramic flatware, chalice and a napkin with an embroidered gold edge. Its base, Heritage Floor, made up of white triangular tiles, holds names of another 999 women. It has travelled for a while and since 2007 is has been on permanent exhibition in the Elizabeth A. Sackler Center for Feminist Art at the Brooklyn Museum, New York.


Henri Matisse
The Painter and his Model (1917)
Oil on canvas
Museum of Modern Art, Paris

''The painter and his Model'' by Henri Matisse emphasizes passive, objectified position of woman in art. While man body is actively creative, female is only an inspiration for pleasure and desire.; woman exists in art as a raw material for man to receive. There seems to be no place for woman's self-expression. The painting also shows basic elements of art making while interacting with a model - there is no lust, passion or touch from either side. It's professional process of studio painting (artist himself and Laurette, the model); ideal conditions for modern art making. Matisse decides to juxtapose his subjects in very unusual way. He paints himself unclothed while his feminine model is fully dressed. Masculine body of the painter can be perhaps associated with Apollonian intelligence, beauty and creativity.


Robert Doisneau
Un regard Oblique (1948)
Robert Doisneau's ''The Oblique Look'' is really intriguing and quite shocking for me. Very simple and cleverly done piece of visual art! Firstly, the perspective of the inside store observer is quite striking. Then we see a middle-age couple looking on the window display and man not quite into the women's source of interest. Nothing unusual, he stares into very sexual, erotic picture of a women in a fancy traditional frame. Focus of his attention is understandable... but the woman stares into nothing from the perspective it's presented; just a black canvas which suggests how unimportant it is. She's also unaware of the situation; she is blinded through the male gaze.


According to Freud little boys apparently believes that he could be mutilated and that male gaze is natural reaction of trying to overcome the threat of potential castration. The Dior J'adore advert seems to use the fetish aspect from Freud's theories where the bottle of perfume signifies completion and satisfaction of a woman in relation to the brand. Woman's look shows her desire for the product, a sex symbol. It's made to be very sensual as a whole, the appearance and body language of the subject and the matching bottle. Golden colour also suggests luxury. In the same time it may raise the sphere of male's alienation and possibly anxiety (Freud terms). Other person would say... a woman's image is appropriated as a commodity to be consumed. In relation to male's phantasy, female figure is styled accordingly. However as women I think we want to be attractive and match these phantasies in a way. It works both ways and attract us to buy a product.

Carmen Kass for JB Mondino
(1999)

Advertising evokes feminist ideas and theories quite a lot and usually not in a serious way. It also uses stereotypes relating to woman. Some ads send the messages that women generally enjoy. A lot of behaviours are determined and driven (often unconsciously) by early habits (for a reason there is a name of fair sex; inspiration like ancient Graces, women always supposed to be desired and admired by men). I wouldn't say it's harmful or disturbing unless it pushes the boundaries and reveals sexism problem, gender rivalry or domination (such as American Apparel ads - their inappropriateness made me speechless). Another example of male domination responding to a fear of woman (Freud) appears in some Hollywood movies by A. Hitchcock as sadistic punishment. A female often becomes no more than erotic object for a spectator; mystified, colonized and alien for male's fantasy.

So to sum up, I think that human rights should be equal to both men and women. I also think everything should have healthy boundaries (especially advertising which doesn't consider children being raised within inappropriateness of their product). Attractivity is subjective. Feminism deals with problem of sexism and its ongoing struggle which surely will continue.






References:

Beuningen, M. (2015). Sarah Lucas - Bitch - 1995. [online] Collectie2008.boijmans.nl. Available at: http://collectie2008.boijmans.nl/en/work/BEK%201678%20a-g%20(MK) [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Judychicago.com, (2015). The Dinner Party Gallery » Gallery » Judy Chicago. [online] Available at: http://www.judychicago.com/gallery.php?name=The+Dinner+Party+Gallery [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Sarah Maple, (2015). New Page. [online] Available at: http://www.sarahmaple.com/ [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Spencer, J. (2015). Feminism and Visuality.

Staleywise.com, (2015). Robert Doisneau. [online] Available at: http://www.staleywise.com/collection/doisneau/doisneau_1.html [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

The Guardian, (2015). SlutWalks | World news | The Guardian. [online] Available at: http://www.theguardian.com/world/slutwalks [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Wikipedia, (2015). Peter Paul Rubens. [online] Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Paul_Rubens [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Wikipedia, (2015). The Painter and His Model. [online] Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Painter_and_His_Model [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].








Monday, 21 December 2015

Incredibly bad: on the difference between paintings that look bad and are bad.


23rd November 2015 

Matthew Bowman has given us a speech today about bad and good art based on his research. He presented numerous examples of ''Bad'' art mostly featured by ugliness, malicious and despicable style. Majority of those paintings contained elements of kitsch, irony, protest and shocking, imaginable perspective. They seemed to be a manifest of their own badness, possibly with hidden meaning and consideration. However they weren't very eye pleasing.
The Museum of Modern Art in Vienna celebrated those painterly freaks in 2008, setting an exhibition entitled ''Bad Painting - Good Art''. It has collected artworks from the 1920s till beginning of 21st century; to surprising or truly shocking, sensationalist, reactionary solutions. It brings examples of twenty-one artists to represent ''bad paintings'' as a phenomenon which has opened to different perspectives in art by using traditional medium and criticising previous approaches (especially modernist utopia). It's an opposition to the doctrines of classical modernism and avant-garde movements, playing with the medium and the subjects, turning into unexpected, darker and ugly approaches. It questions aesthetics in art. It also surely influence somehow on contemporary practice. I think it may tries to show value of kitsch and anything that used to be worthless, even artists skills in some cases, I suppose.

Asger Jorn
 L'Avantgarde se rend pas (1962)



André Butzer Frau
 Ölauf Leinwan (2002)

I think that Bad Painting can be a good art (such as E. Manet's ''Olympia'' from 1863, which was declared as really bad and inappropriate at first and then became a masterpiece). Judgements of art highly depend on viewer's taste and cultural sensitivity, time and place the art is displayed or simply the knowledge necessary to understand it and bring out its deeper meaning. Knowledge supports our judgement and can change our impressions. I'm sure it happened to everybody, while walking into the gallery or museum, to see an artwork not appealing to us at all. We then ask ourselves, what is this thing doing here?! It shouldn't be classified as art, it's simply a piece of crap. Well I have experienced that quite recently, remembering the trip to Tate Modern in London and some work in the ''Collection Display. Making Traces'' exhibition.

Catalogue cover (2008)
Before modernism appeared and questioned the nature of art, bad painting equalled to be a bad artist. Painting and sculpture art were separated. In 1980s postmodernist anti-painting supposed to revolutionise art once again, I recon (deconstructive approach against ''good painting''). It was something different and made you look. Anything modernist had rather happy approach, while bad painting seem to be darker and rather creepy. There is a difference between paintings that are bad and those which just look bad. However I don't think it's a perfect theory. In my opinion there is some sort of general aesthetic that majority of people can label as bad or good. Although nothing is possibly more subjective (opinions). Facts are objective, but who make them? Who put these artworks in a canon of bad or as being a masterpiece and marvellous? It's usually up to what critics say about it or possibly other authorities in the past... maybe general opinion... However I think its purely individual choice to categorize that. It can be often wrong due to lack of required knowledge (like in the example of red paintings where the appearance is identical, but intensions are different and so, some of them are classified as art and some aren't). I think the most important thing in the classification is actual feeling the art piece reveals in the spectator, while additional information about it is excluded. I disagree that the only thing to make a painting good art is meaning behind it.

I really like Thomas Kinkade's Disney collectible paintings. I think it takes a great skill to create such canvases and they're fantastic aesthetically, but there isn't any deeper meaning behind them. I still would give them an art status. ''Thomas Kinkade captured the timeless magic of classic Disney stories and their captivating characters through the style of “narrative panoramas”. Each painting tells the entire story of a Disney film in one image, taking inspiration from art, sketches and other historic documents from the Disney Archives.'' (Thomaskinkade.com, 2015). I like how magic, detailed and colour live they are. They're also so recent! Tradition in contemporary times once again.

Cindarella


Cinderella 2015

Tangled

Beauty and the Beast

Andy Warhol's pop art sculpture ''Brillo Box'' (1964) caused quite a bit of controversy in the 1960s. The artist has decided to use very ordinary, consumer-product related imagery and turn it into sculptures. For this reason he hired carpenters to make him some wooden boxes which he then covered with paint and silkscreened logo (he made few different ones:  Kellogg's corn flakes, Brillo soap pads, Mott's apple juice, Del Monte peaches and Heinz ketchup). Then he created installations and exhibited them in the museum. He also wanted to sell them to collectors as stacks, but it haven't gone well. Considered as art it caused a lot of controversy with its commercial subject, reminding products on the supermarket shelf and perfectly factorial look, contrasting with sensitive abstract expressionist paintings. In this case I think its very sensual matter. Even the general look was very similar, the actual art object by Andy Warhol surely felt differently and if compared, it would be easily identified.

Andy Warhol
Brillo Box (1964)


''We were having a fairly heady discussion about art, religion, and culture by the time we climbed onto the fifth floor and breathlessly approached the Brillo Boxes. There my thoughts wandered from connections between religious icons and pop culture to a small closet in my kitchen where I have a similar box, crumpled and rusty, stuffed between the Windex and the Comet cleanser.
In all my years of scrubbing with sponges, mops, steel wool, I have rarely stopped to notice the packaging. I just ripped the boxes open and started my work. But these elevated Brillo Boxes show me that we are surrounded by art. It lines the aisles of our supermarkets. It decorates our homes. It festoons our trash bins: pungent red, flashing yellow, telltale white.
My pantry is now a gallery and my chores interactive art.''
Reverend Gail Ransom, East Liberty Presbyterian Church quoted for The Point of View Label Project, The Andy Warhol Museum, 1999.

“[The boxes] were very difficult to sell.  He thought that everyone was going to buy them on sight, he really and truly did.  We all had visions of people walking down Madison Avenue with these boxes under their arms, but we never saw them.”
Eleanor Ward, art dealer: Stable Gallery, in Warhol by David Bourdon, Harry N. Abrams, Inc. (New York, 1995), p.186.


Read more at warhol.org: http://www.warhol.org/education/resourceslessons/Brillo--But-is-it-Art-/#ixzz3txT2SIug

Martin Kippenberger (1953–1997), German contemporary artist was very important persona influencing Matthew Bowman's research. Kippenberger was known for his very creative and innovative approach in wide range of styles and media and artistic provocateur (sometimes called 'Deutschland’s Andy Warhol'). There were few examples of his work that I have found really interesting, such as ''One of You, a German in Florence'' (1976-77) which consisted of 83 paintings that put on the top of each other would equal painter's height or ''Lieber Maler, male mir…'' underneath.

Martin Kippenberger
Untitled. Lieber Maler, male mir… (Dear Painter, paint for me...) 1983
Oil on canvas



 

The painting is based on a photograph and it well looks like a photograph itself (photorealistic approach). It is part of a twelve paintings series, one of the earliest and most important works of the artist. It represents back perspective of two almost tragi-comic looking figures, heading on a bar crawl through the streets of Düsseldorf. It's great demonstration and clear identification of Kippenberger's style; ordinariness of the scene and extraordinary manner of representation as a slick hyper-realistic oil painting. The artist commissioned it to be made for him by the film poster painter known as 'Mr Werner'. It's a strong statement about Kippenberger's self-identity and it emphasizes its authenticity (purpose and method of making). It reflects, possibly more than any of his other works, his life style of constant movement in life and in art, by changing locations and questioning artistic conventions. As any of human being, author's gaze is restricted with the mirror image to identify himself, so he becomes a participant of his own art. It's really interesting way of self-expression.


 
Martin Kippenberger
Heavy Burschi / Heavy Guy 1989/90
Installation view at Tate 2006
Martin Kippenberger questioned the role and existence of the author and it is also considered throughout his other artworks, such as ''Heavy Burschi'' or ''Model Interconti''. In the first case artist presents an idea of author's death and gives his installation status of ''double kitsch'' (Jubilee Centre, 2011). His creations are mostly made out of borrowed commercial art and copied as paintings by his studio assistant while dissatisfied Kippenberger trashed them all and they were then displayed in the wooden container in the gallery besides photographs of the same series placed on the walls.

Kippenberger bought a 1972 grey abstract painting by Gerhard Richter and transformed it into a sculpture, a table. ''Model Interconti'' is considered a masterpiece of contemporary art. But there is now quite an issue with the authorship. Under the German law Kippenberger supposed to be sole author of the new work. However what about moral rights for Richter? It is quite complicated and I read an interesting text about it online at http://artasiapacific.com/Magazine/64/ModelIntercourse. He has questioned here the art market and cleverly critiqued social connotations between artworks. 
Martin Kippenberger
 Model Interconti 1987
(table made with Gerhard Richter painting)
Collection of Gaby and Wilhelm Schürmann



This lecture has shown me that good painting is not necessarily visually pleasing and opposite. Bad looking art, clearly pointing into its badness, can be often a great art manifesto. However to give this status to an artwork, I think I usually judge mostly aesthetically and ethically. I think that's the first thing a lot of people do - decide if they're visually pleased with an art and if it talks to them, making a connection. The other time the artwork could be pointed to particular audience or send a message the viewer won't like, but if it's good painting, that won't change (it reminds me again of Manet's ''Olympia'' that was banned at first, only because the lack of critiqued by a painter society's approval).




I have also find some more facts about Bad Painting in America and another art exhibition curated by Marcia Tucker in New York, where paintings were only ironically called ''Bad''.


"Bad" Painting is the name given to a trend in American figurative painting in the 1970s by critic and curator, Marcia Tucker (1940–2006). She curated an exhibition of the same name, featuring the work of fourteen artists, most unknown in New York at the time, at the New Museum of Contemporary Art, New York. The exhibition ran from January 14 to February 28, 1978. "Bad" Painting was not a demonstration of technical incompetence, poor artistic judgement, amateur or outsider dabbling, the term is commonly used for these. For Tucker, it denoted a more focused or deliberate disrespect for recent styles. The press release for the exhibition summarised "Bad" Painting as ‘…an ironic title for ‘good painting’, which is characterized by deformation of the figure, a mixture of art-historical and non-art resources, and fantastic and irreverent content. In its disregard for accurate representation and its rejection of conventional attitudes about art, ‘bad’ painting is at once funny and moving, and often scandalous in its scorn for the standards of good taste.’ Her use of quotation marks around "Bad" points to this special meaning. "Bad" here, is thus a term of approval for the more eccentric and amusing variations on certain accepted styles, at that time.

(Wikipedia)





Resources:

Artnet.com, (2015). artnet Magazine. [online] Available at: http://www.artnet.com/magazineus/features/saltz/saltz3-20-09_detail.asp?picnum=7 [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Bowman, M. (2015). Incredibly bad: on the difference between paintings that look bad and are bad.

Gallery, S. and Gallery, S. (2015). Martin Kippenberger - Artist's Profile - The Saatchi Gallery. [online] Saatchigallery.com. Available at: http://www.saatchigallery.com/artists/martin_kippenberger.htm [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Huma3-archive.com, (2008). Exhibition in Wien: Bad Painting - International Art Portal Huma3. [online] Available at: http://www.huma3-archive.com/huma3-eng-reviews-id-313.html [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Jubilee Centre, (2011). Outside the frame: Postmodern art by Anne Roberts - Jubilee Centre. [online] Available at: http://www.jubilee-centre.org/outside-the-frame-postmodern-art-by-anne-roberts/ [Accessed 21 Dec. 2015].

Tate.org.uk, (2015). Martin Kippenberger. [online] Available at: http://www.tate.org.uk/whats-on/tate-modern/exhibition/martin-kippenberger [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Thomaskinkade.com, (2015). Disney Images | The Thomas Kinkade Company. [online] Available at: https://thomaskinkade.com/art-genre/disney-images/ [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Warhol.org, (2015). warhol: Brillo: But is it Art?. [online] Available at: http://www.warhol.org/education/resourceslessons/Brillo--But-is-it-Art-/ [Accessed 10 Dec. 2015].

Sunday, 20 December 2015

KOYAANISQATSI 'Life out of balance' by Godfrey Reggio and the team


23rd November 2015 


 

Today I've seen quite unusual movie called KOYAANISQATSI (1982) by Godfrey Reggio (producer and creative director), Ron Frickle (photography) and Phillip Glass (music). It was the longest movie with no words I have ever seen and an amazing journey through the world history from its very beginning until now. II think, it was all about taking a journey, not really about its exact destination. It took six years and lots of effort and expense to create the film, but I agree with the producers that it was well worth it.  

The title was taken from Hopi language and it could be translated as 'Life out of balance'. This film is defined as postmodernist critique of existing world, where one way of life always calls for another. The production is extraordinary for many reasons. It describes indescribable, it doesn't have formal narrative or cultural baggage, as it has non-literate form. It goes beyond words and it's breaking the boundaries of traditional cinematography. The music and imagery are employed instead, to build the atmosphere and story allowed to be created in viewer's mind (which is intended by the authors).  It was made by an enormous team and it has as many authors as spectators, because we're all involved in it as we watch. It's up to us how we experience the subject. I also find it amazing because it was created through very complex and rather difficult process with pre-digital, analogue cameras. The production builds an emotional connection with the audience through rapidly changing sequences, through eye contact between the viewer and the characters, turning points, such as moon shadowed by the skyscraper or apocalyptical city buildings collapsing.


It was also quite spiritual experience, it was like looking at the world from behind the scene, from different perspective, possibly from God's perspective. I think, the concept related to cave paintings (from very basic stage of human kind) or maybe also to biblical act of creation.
I've noticed that during first twenty minutes there isn't any appearance of human at all. It has got a frame of the same image and music (identical in the beginning and in the end; some sort of cave painting and meditative singing). As we've listened to a few words from creators afterwards, it was inspired by very universal symbol of an 'eye in a triangle' (a signifier of God). Generally it gives national feel and it can be universally translated. It shows how fragile our life is, how constant is cycle of life and its essence. It relates to numerous aspects of living, such as ecological issues and technological progress, mass culture or art. It's a peculiar contemplation of life. We never really know what it can bring.

Movie creators didn't know what the outcome is going to be straight away. There is an aspect of Dolce Vita ('Sweet Life'), but also threat of life, injustice, dramatic changes, explosions and loosing control. It shows everything within human life and technology. Reggio states that everything, such as politics, education, language, the culture, religion, finances, nations exists within technology; we live technology. Well... that's where human destined himself... through progress to the world we live in now. Technology indeed took over big part of our lives, but I disagree that everything exists within it. When thinking of a title, I reckon it was a good choice and great concept. It forms its universal character and together with lack of words during the movie, describes indescribable. I think the point gets across with considerate collage and dynamic juxtapositions of images and music.


Poster: Conor Culhane (2015)

Before the human kind appears the 'KOYAANISQATSI' film seems to be a bit boring and tiring for the viewer; scenes are repeated and monotonous. I think the first twenty minutes and some of urban movement in later stage could be slightly reduced to possibly become more interesting from the beginning, right to the end. That's the only thing I would change a little bit. Besides I think it's an amazing production! It's for anybody, it's universal and relates to anyone, to any human. It's like an artistic sight of world existence, a physical visual form of its history. Changes in imagery and a plot are identified by music coordinated with movement and emotions. There are sequences easy to separate. It made me think of continuousness and crumbliness of life. The beginning is all about nature and its power shown from very different angles, shown alive and changing speed. It's about development of towns and cities; its about The Beginning.

After first twenty minutes of the movie I got actually a bit bored and impatient at first. But the first impression has changed and my overall overview gives it a masterpiece status. There're rocks, islands (earth), mosaic of fields (it seems like you swimming while looking), clouds rapidly or very slowly moving (feels a bit like flying in the sky), water, explosions (fire). So there are all four elements of natural power. In about twenty-second minute proper image of people appears (couple of minutes before it would be just human shape). They're looking high up on the glass skyscrapers reflecting the clouds, looking quite surprised, happy, wondering... Then we've got an aeroplane appearing in very hypnotic way, busy urban landscape and age of cars, human masses and all of it was like short-lived illusion. Afterwards there is a war... tanks and rocket exploding into the galactic space... and then city again with its enormous buildings. Three men sitting on the street and others just passing through time to time. Now it reminds me of God a little, as being one but in three persons. And generally I have started to think of it as we were shown God's perspective in the movie... especially after seeing a bit of inspiration from the authors - the eye closed in a triangle (symbolic).




There's beautiful semiotic language applied all the way through the film. Wind, shadows, flock of birds flying there and back, symbols of period of particular times in history. There's a very apocalyptic view of collapsing cities, fog and clouds uncovering birth of new ones. Life goes back to the cycle... American life style (day and night cycle, street lights show, music and image speeding up in final time-laps, 'rat race'), machinery, manufactories and distribution, underground rush again, consumerism and first appearance of computers (it feels like people are marionettes played by time). More cars, subways, lifts, buildings, products... Although I've said before that the movie is universal, it's very accented by American culture, especially nearer the end while the flag is exposed. It goes through the tunnel of news and TV invention, through different styles and subcultures, modernism. Two men sit in the car and seem to move towards the future. 1hour 3 minutes - the first time movie is completely silent for few seconds, before an anxious music continues.





The most influencing and touching moment was to get into an eye contact with some characters. Suddenly viewer feels observed and it becomes almost 3D motion. Really striking for me was seeing a man shaving his beard randomly in the middle of the pavement (looking towards us as into his reflection in the mirror) or quite old woman intensively smoking a cigarette. Afterwards shadows appear and it starts snowing, but it looked a bit like someone was ripping a piece of paper. In the end a rocket explodes again into space for a little while and then it falls slowly back down in blue background firing gently again. The emotional piano music has followed the contemplative singing bit.